The Truth About Dishonesty 20130525

這次星期六討論的主題是The Truth About Dishonesty，也就是上面的影片，討論人為什麼會欺騙，以及有哪些方法可以減少欺騙行為的發生，以及從心理學以及社會的角度去探討這些方法有效的原因。

詳情可以看主講人節錄的重點和帶大家討論的問題：http://goo.gl/t0l7D

以及我們討論前觀看的影片

RSA Animate - The Truth About Dishonesty:

中文字幕：

這次主要討論的問題如下：

How is taking a pencil more acceptable than taking money?

How does cheating leads to tremendous economic impact?

Why is illegal downloading more common than walking from restaurant without paying?

Do you agree that all cheating should be treated with the same level?

Does the effect depend on its content? (For example, reminding of statements on cheating is good) 

Is it good (or helpful) to limit mankind with morality?

Do you think that the New Page Mechanism will somehow help people with rationalization?

Is there a way to make bankers feel clean again? Is it good to do so?

How? Will the situation be better if financial industry vanish?
Do you think that the lecturer is finding excuse for major morality violations? By comparing them with minor ones? Why or why not?

以下是另外兩個相關的影片，有興趣的歡迎自行觀看：(第二個有英文字幕)
The truth about dishonesty完整版 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZGGxguJsirI
What Promotes Positive Health? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wfqwl57q23I

下面是這次的討論狀況：

這次討論進行的比預期好很多，一方面是主持人控制得好，一方面是大家都能發表對此問題發表自己的意見，影片只有十分鐘問題也不算多卻讓大家討論了兩小時多，比我預期的 1~1.5 hr.要長不少。

我覺得這次討論雖然準備匆忙了點但還算成功，大家都有提出自己的看法，我也有學到新東西。